Spartan vs Immortal
Spartan vs Immortal in Command An Army: both 4-star units at 0.19% odds, but one is a defensive wall and the other a rush breaker. Which fits your formation.
Verdict
Spartan if you defend, Immortal if you attack. Both are S tier — the better pick is the one that covers your formation's weakness, not the one with bigger numbers.
Quick Answer: Spartan or Immortal?
Spartan is the defensive meta pick — the highest HP pool in the game behind a shield, best at holding capture points. Immortal is the offensive counterpart — it spawns 24 troops per spawn and breaks through defensive lines on the charge. Both cost the same 0.19% summon odds and neither can evolve. If your matches are decided on defense, Spartan wins; if you keep failing to break enemy walls, Immortal wins.
| Stat | Spartan | Immortal |
|---|---|---|
| Stars | 4★ | 4★ |
| Summon odds | 0.19% | 0.19% |
| Role | Shield-and-spear holder | Rush infantry |
| HP | Highest in game (est.) | High, but below Spartan |
| Damage | ~30.7 per thrust (Lv 10) | ~45 per strike (est.) |
| Troops per spawn | Standard | 24 (per a level 50 player) |
| Best at | Holding points, defense | Charges, breaking lines |
| Evolution | None | None |
Why Spartan Is the Defensive Pick
Spartan's shield blocks incoming projectiles while its spear holds melee at range — the reason launch-week metas parked Spartans behind Shieldmen on every defended point. Its sustained HP pool outlasts everything else on the field, which is exactly what a capture-point holder needs. The counter is block damage: Update 1's Mace and Halberder exist specifically to break Spartan walls.
Why Immortal Is the Offensive Pick
Immortal trades some of Spartan's HP for overwhelming spawn count and charge damage — 24 troops per spawn means single-target defenses simply cannot kill them fast enough. It is the answer to the defensive meta Immortal's own rarity tier helped create: walls stop units, but not floods.
Which Should You Build Around?
You rarely choose — at 0.19% odds you field whichever one the banner gives you. But for loadout decisions under the star limit (four slots): Spartan pairs with Shieldman walls and Crossbowman fire support; Immortal pairs with cavalry (Scout Rider path) for flanking charges. If you own both, Spartan on defense maps, Immortal on attack maps.
Last updated: September 19, 2026